Skip to main content

Tyranny of our Remembering selves






I was catching up over a cup of coffee with my elder brother when I happened to see the biggest dog I had seen yet in my life.  I quickly told my brother to get his phone out because mine happened to be dead.

He looked at me calmly and said these exact words: “Why? Are you in tyranny of your remembering self?”

 I gave him a blank look. Frankly, I was dumbfounded. I asked him to explain what he meant and that was how I got to know about the tyranny of remembering self. At first, it did not make sense to me at the time, per say, but the more I thought about it, the more it made sense.

Tyranny of remembering self refers to the idea that to most people, the most wonderful experiences have little or no value if those experiences cannot be remembered. This is the reason we are so obliged, so caught up, so determined to take pictures of each and everything: desperate to catch hold of the moment.

As pointed out by psychologist Daniel Kahneman in his book “Thinking: Fast and Slow”, we seem to have two selves, an experiencing self and a remembering self.

“The Experiencing self is the one that answers the question: does it hurt now? The remembering self is the one that answers the question: how was it, on the whole?” Memories are all we get from our experience of living, and the only perspective that we can adopt as we think about our lives is therefore that of the remembering self.

The experiencing self does not have a voice. The remembering self is sometimes wrong, but it is the one that keeps score and governs what we learn from living, and it is the one that make decisions. What we learn from the past is to maximize the qualities of our future memories, not necessarily of our future experience. This is the tyranny of the remembering self.”

-Psychologist Daniel Kahneman

I think we’ve all fallen into the tyranny of our remembering selves deeper after the digital age and the era of the smartphone. It is so damn easy to click pictures of everything with your phone with you all the time, unlike the old times when you had to own a good camera for pictures. It has made us take moments for granted, time for granted. We are so intrigued, so involved in capturing the moment in pictures or videos that we do not actually enjoy the moment.

We do this a lot. I’m guilty, you’re guilty; we’re all guilty. We’ve all fallen into the tyranny of our remembering selves.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Rajamati

I think we’ve all heard the song of Rajamati growing up. It is so popular that many people in Nepal claim this is the only Newari song that they have heard. The song was written some 200 years back. The first few lines go like this, which I’m sure you must have heard of, unless you’ve been living under a rock: Rājamati kumati, jike wasā pirati Hāya bābā Rājamati-chā Rājamati mabila dhāsā Kāshi wane tela bubā Hayā biu Rājamati-chā. San dhāsā kuli kuli, mikhā dhāsā bālā bālā Sakumi yā mhyāy machā lā Khwā dhāsā tuyu khwā, khwālay niga tee du Tāhā Nani yā Rājamati-chā. It is said to be written by or rather from the perspective of a man who was infatuated and in awe of the beauty of Rajamati. He describes with great admiration: her hair, her eyes, her complexion and the little moles on her face. However it is unknown who the writer of this beautiful song is. The song rushed into popularity after it was played in England in 1850 when Prime Minister Jung Bahadur Rana vi...
5 comments
Read more

Best Places for Breakfast in Kathmandu

The only reason I love sleep, more than the reason that, well, it’s sleep, is that it’s like time travelling to breakfast.  Yeah, no kidding. Breakfast, the most important meal of the day. Whoever named that meal breakfast, was straightforward. I don’t know who named lunch and dinner, but the breakfast guy? He cut in straight to the point, didn’t he? Because breakfast is literally breaking your 8-10 hours fast. Eat breakfast like a king, lunch like a prince, and dinner like a pauper, they say. So, you don’t really want to compromise on breakfast now, do you? Now, this is no backlashing, but in many restaurants around town, the most breakfast things they have on the menu are omelet and toast. Yeah, I was disappointed too. There’s this restaurant in Mangal Bazar, where my best friend and I met up early morning. We decided to have breakfast. The restaurant overlooks the courtyard so it’s a beautiful place to talk over a cup of coffee or tea. She and I ordered a cheese ...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Oldest Kumari

Dhana Kumari Bajracharya resides amidst the hustle and bustle in Gabahal, Patan. She is a 70 year old woman, who you would think is much younger at age, if you look at her. Age seems to have done justice to this beautiful woman. What makes this wise old woman different than other wise old women in Patan? She is the oldest Kumari of Patan. Kumari, the living goddess is a tradition or a practice that has been around for many years and that has been celebrated widely in the Kathmandu Valley. The very first Kumari goes back to 17 th Century. The process to choose the Kumari is divine and a girl must go through several tests to get chosen as the Kumari. Dhana Kumari Bajracharya is the longest serving Kumari of Patan having been established as the Kumari from 2010 B.S to 2042 B.S. A whooping 32 years. Perhaps her case is the most rare that we might come across. A girl serves as a Kumari until she reaches puberty, or she has her first menstruation. After that, it is believed that th...
1 comment
Read more